Twice the Charm mystery jewelry jar with a gold lid, filled with surprise jewelry

A surprise worth opening

Mystery
Jewelry Jars

Pop the lid. Find the fun.

A little sparkle, a little suspense, and a whole lot to discover. Pick a themed surprise or tell us what you love—we’ll curate your jar.

Curate your jar Explore the jars ↓

Custom jars: allow 2–4 weeks before shipping. Ready-to-ship jars are ready now. Check each listing for details.

A little outfit inspiration Shop the complete looks ♡ →
5 pieces to explore
Filters
Clear all
Custom mystery jewelry jar with a gold lid and Twice the Charm label; contents shown are an example.
Hot
New
Pre-order
Out stock

SKU:

AVAILABILITY: In stock

PRODUCT TYPE: Mystery Jewelry Jar

Tell us what you love, and we’ll curate a jewelry surprise around your preferences. Choose your jar • Small: 8oz • Medium: 12oz • Large: 16oz How it works Choose a size, then use the available curation selections to share...

$45.00
View this piece
Shop Piece →
Halloween mystery jewelry jar with an example assortment of spooky pieces; actual contents vary.
Hot
New
-21%
Pre-order
Out stock

SKU:

AVAILABILITY: In stock

PRODUCT TYPE: Mystery Jewelry Jar

A little spooky-season surprise for your jewelry collection, with Halloween-themed pieces gathered in a mystery jar. What’s inside • A Halloween jewelry assortment that may include necklaces, earrings, rings and bracelets. • Designs, colors and selection that vary from jar...

$125.00$99.99
View this piece
Shop Piece →
Christmas mystery jewelry jar with a red holiday-print lid and example festive assortment.
Hot
New
-44%
Pre-order
Out stock

SKU: TTCB-CMJAR-001

AVAILABILITY: In stock

PRODUCT TYPE: Mystery Jewelry Jar

A festive jewelry surprise with Christmas colors and seasonal details, gathered in a clear jar with a cheerful red lid. What’s inside • An assortment of Christmas-inspired earrings and necklaces. • Gold-tone and silver-tone finishes with colorful holiday accents shown...

$29.99$16.99
View this piece
Shop Piece →
Gold-lidded mystery earring jewelry jar with example contents, angled view on light fabric.
Hot
New
-38%
Pre-order
Out stock

SKU: TTCB-MJAR-EAR-001

AVAILABILITY: In stock

PRODUCT TYPE: Mystery Jewelry Jar

For the person who always has room for another pair of earrings, this jar offers a surprise assortment to explore one matching set at a time. What’s inside • Earrings only, presented as matching sets in a clear jar with...

$39.99$24.99
View this piece
Shop Piece →
Christian Cross mystery jewelry jar with colorful cross pendants and beads; contents shown are an example.
Hot
New
-14%
Pre-order
Out stock

SKU: TTCB-CJJ-001

AVAILABILITY: In stock

PRODUCT TYPE: Mystery Jewelry Jar

Crosses, meaningful symbols and colorful details come together in this faith-inspired jewelry assortment. The mix includes earrings, necklaces, bracelets, rings and other individual pieces. The photographed collection shows cross designs, religious imagery, beads, chains, pendants and charms, including a Philippians...

$75.00$65.00
View this piece
Shop Piece →
Twice the Charm Boutique

How can we help?

Send us a message about your order, shipping, returns, products, or anything else you need help with.

For return requests, please contact us within 7 calendar days of confirmed delivery.